Following are the Prime Minister, Dr. Manmohan Singh’s closing remarks
at the 57TH meeting of National Development Council in New Delhi today:
“We have had a very full and long day of deliberations. I thank all
Chief Ministers for complying with the electronically imposed time
limit. Had they not complied with the limit, we would not have been able
to accommodate 40 speakers even in this long session.
I assure all Chief Ministers that we have taken note of the points
raised by them, including those in the written speeches. All these
points will be carefully considered by the Planning Commission.
Many of the points are broadly in conformity with what has been said in
the Plan document. There are also some points which suggest a different
A Plan is not a rigid blue print. It is a broad “directional” and
“aspirational” document, which must allow for modification on the basis
of experience. We will keep this in mind as we implement the Plan, and
make improvements and modifications in consultation with the States as
we go along.
The lowering of the growth target to 8 percent has been commented on by
some CMs. Several CMs have recognized that this is only a realistic
refection of the external constraints on growth.
Some CMs have asserted that they will aim for a higher growth rate. I
welcome this determination to do better. Some states will indeed do
better than the average, and I commend their effort.
Several Chief Ministers emphasized the importance of sectors such as
Agriculture, Power, Other Infrastructure, Health, Education and Skill
development. The Twelfth Five Year Plan document reflects these
Several CMs also focused on the need for special consideration for
backward States, and also for backward areas within States. I fully
share this concern. States with low-income levels already get more
resources under the formula used by the Finance Commission, and also the
Gadgil-Mukherjee formula, which is used by the Planning Commission to
distribute Normal Central Assistance.
In addition, we have the modality of the Backward Regions Grant Fund (BRGF).
Under the BRGF, a large number of Districts received special assistance
in the Eleventh Plan. There are also State Specific Packages for Bihar,
KBK Districts of Orissa, Bundelkhand Districts of MP& UP, and most
recently West Bengal.
The Planning Commission is currently working on a restructured design of
BRGF, which will come into effect from next year. We will try to reflect
the concern of CMs by recognizing the special needs of the extremely
backward areas. The restructured BRGF will provide substantial
additional funds to make an impact.
Several Chief Ministers have drawn attention to the problem of fuel
availability affecting power plants. This is indeed an urgent problem,
which needs to be tackled. I am requesting the Planning Commission to
make a quick review of the situation and submit a report to me within
three weeks. I would request all CMs to write to the Deputy Chairman of
the Planning Commission giving details of Plants, which they feel are
I was happy to hear of initiatives in solar energy in some States. I
have asked the Planning Commission to review the innovative steps under
consideration in various States to see how we can give greater momentum
to this area.
With these words, I thank all the distinguished participants for their
contribution. We must now devote all our energies to implementing the
Plan and I thank each one of you for your contribution and for your